How to Navigate the Challenges of Laser Marking Plastics

Blog

How to Navigate the Challenges of Laser Marking Plastics

by MECCO
0
How to navigate the challenges of laser marking plastics “When you get into laser marking on plastics, you’re stepping into a tricky realm,” says laser applications guru Josh Christley. “In many ways, it’s totally different from marking metals. Metals are relatively straightforward. But plastics are complex; that’s what makes them so versatile. And with that complexity you get a touch of uncertainty.”

So how can a manufacturer demystify the issues, identify the clues, and uncover the right decisions?

“Here’s the key,” Josh says. “Accept the fact that no two applications are exactly the same. View any blanket statement about laser marking on plastics with caution. Realize that your situation is unique, and that it will take some deep analysis to get the right solution.” 

 As MECCO’s applications manager, Josh and his team keep busy helping manufacturers make evidence-based decisions that put fast, efficient laser marking to work on production lines that handle parts and products of a wide variety of materials, including plastic. Recently he slowed down long enough to answer a few questions about his specialized domain.


Laser Marking Expert Q&A: Can You Laser Engrave Plastics? 


Q: So, laser marking IS a practical solution for plastic parts?

Josh: Oh, of course. It’s been a reliable workhorse across a whole spectrum of industries for decades. Aerospace, medical supplies and devices, semiconductors, automotive manufacturing … every week I see new sub-sectors integrate laser marking with their production lines to engrave plastic parts with text (like serial numbers and part numbers); machine-readable data (barcodes, Unique ID codes, 2D codes); or graphics (logos and other branding marks).   



Compared to lasers, other direct marking techniques like dot peening don’t always play well with plastic shapes and surfaces. And both printing and adhesive labels fall short in terms of cost (think of the consumables), environmental impact, permanence, visibility, speed, flexibility, and maintenance. So laser marking makes a lot of sense, for plastics as well as other materials.
 
“Accept the fact that no two applications are exactly the same. View any blanket statement about laser marking on plastics with caution.  Realize that your situation is unique, and that it will take some deep analysis to get the right solution.” 
- Josh Christley, Applications Manager, MECCO

Q: But there’s no one-size-fits-all approach for laser-marking plastics, is there?

Josh: Correct. That’s true when you’re marking metals, as well. The same ground rules apply any time you’re looking for a laser system to match your application: For a smooth, low-risk transition to a new technology, the first priority is to connect with a vendor who’s willing to help you deep-dive into your processes, goals, and business. That’s how you get a system that’s going to work for you.

Those are the fundamentals for working with any material. It’s when the material is a polymer or a composite that things start to get interesting.

Q: You’ve said marking metals is relatively straightforward. What makes plastics marking so complicated?

Josh: It’s like the difference between checkers and chess.

To begin, we custom-design every system we build to match the properties of the production material as closely as 21st-century science and engineering allow. Nothing is off-the-shelf. That means we have to know a lot more about your raw material than you might imagine.

Just look at the variety of resins in common use. All the polys: polyamide, polycarbonate, polyethylene, polypropylene, polyoxymethylene, polyarylsulfone, polyether ketone,  polyimide, polystyrene, polymethylmetacrylate, polyester, polyethylene terephthalate. Then you have Delrin, silicone, olefins, butadiene, styrene, and so on. Each behaves in its own way, and each will respond differently to variations in laser type, power setting, and pulse duration.



Another twist: Any of those compounds can behave differently from batch to batch, especially if re-ground resins go into the mix.

Furthermore, material from one resin manufacturer may vary, in some subtle way, from another maker’s nominally similar product. That’s why, when our manufacturing partners change suppliers, I always advise them to ship us a sample run of parts made from the new material. Our Quality Assurance lab will test the new parts under the same conditions that applied when we designed the customer’s system, and raise a flag if any concerns arise. Later on, our archive of physical samples and consistent test data can help your in-house troubleshooters track down causes and cures for any production-line irregularities that might pop up.

Resource for You: Have you changed suppliers or just want to get a better mark on your plastic parts? Take advantage of our Free Sample Marking today.


Q: But that just covers the pure resin. What about fillers, extenders, and other additives?

Josh: For reasons unrelated to marking, resins usually contain additives selected for the specific part, product, process, and price point. Not uncommonly, production materials contain 50 percent or more of fillers like calcium carbonate, calcium metasilicate, talc, mica, or gypsum, or even glass fibers. All of the above —and more — can affect the interaction of laser and plastic. Additives optimize the material for its purpose, but they also present the laser system designer with another set of variables.

Have I mentioned color yet? Let me give you just two examples: A fiber laser, for instance, can’t effectively mark white Delrin or clear polypropylene because the fiber wavelength — 1,064 nm — passes right through the material. The same laser can, however, put a legible, khaki-colored mark on Delrin that’s been pigmented with light-absorbing carbon black. 

Another solution might be to coat a white or transparent part with a clear, nanoparticle-bearing polymer film that selectively absorbs the appropriate wavelength.

Color is hardly ever a trivial issue, however. Factors like customer specs or pre-existing FDA approvals can make a color change impractical. Instead, you and your laser tech partner may rethink your choices of power setting, marking effect, or laser type.

Q: What do you mean by “rethink your choice of marking effect”?

Josh: Depending on the wavelength of the light, the delivered wattage, and the composition of the surface itself, laser markers work by producing a variety of controlled changes in color or texture on or in plastic surfaces. The effects include:
  • Ablation or vaporization
  • Foaming or frothing
  • Chemical or molecular alteration
  • Charring
  • Engraving
  • Melting
Engineering or esthetic considerations may dictate the best marking effect for the job, although certain combinations of laser technology and surface materials may narrow the range of options.

Q: Why would you also need to consider rethinking your “laser type”?

Josh: There’s no single class of lasers that’s ideal for all applications. For marking plastics, the MECCO team usually recommends a system built around an industry-tested technology, the CO2 laser marking machine. It provides reliable, cost-effective performance and high-quality marking for plastics and a wide range of other materials. CO2 marking is a low-risk solution when you’re replacing other marking technologies, such as dot peen or non-permanent methods like ink jet or labeling.

When high contrast and minimal surface disruption are critical, conventional fiber laser marking machines and diode-pumped lasers are two proven alternatives.

Q: It sounds like the range of variables and possible solutions is staggering. How do you even begin to sort them out?

Josh: In some ways, it’s as simple as the first question most customers ask: “Can you mark my plastic?”  

In response, we’ve developed a system we call The MECCO Experience that leads our team and the customer through a logical decision-making process. We have a process for rigorously defining the requirements, assessing their technical feasibility, and designing a custom solution.

Every step is evidence-based. We not only test each customer’s material before we even think about selling a machine; we make a point of testing the exact product or part that will come down the production line. That means we have to find out how many resin vendors supply the project, and test samples from each vendor. With test results in hand, we may investigate possible changes in material composition or color for better performance.

Along the way, we’ll ask about things you may not have had on your radar. For example, how hot will your part be when it reaches the marking station? Odd as it may sound, temperature matters. Manufacturers often want to mark the part with a “born-on” date right away. But some plastics — say, in the molding industry — take time to cool down, cure, and stabilize. The room-temperature sample part we test in the lab may respond to marking differently from the same part right out of the mold.

Details, details. Anyway, whichever laser system vendor you work with should provide equivalent levels of service, analysis, and attention to detail.

Q: Anything you’d like to add to help de-mystify laser marking on plastics?

Josh: As I said: Yes, there are a lot of variables to consider. But the potential rewards of laser marking plastics — cost savings, productivity, reduced risk and down time — are huge.

Just being aware that there is complexity, and that there’s no such thing as a quickie, one-size-fits-all solution, is an important first step. Laying the groundwork, doing your homework, getting expert advice will pay off. It is do-able, one small step at a time.

Comments (0)

RSS / RSS Archive

Find the Right Marking Partner for You

Your company should get the best mark every time – whether you partner with MECCO or not! Download this complete checklist for the critical questions to ask when shopping for a marking equipment supplier.